Better than Shagle: why the comparison keeps failing
The question gets asked constantly and answered badly, so here is why it resists an answer.
Two rooms, one network
Your video is carried by neither service. It travels device to device on whatever the networks are not using, which makes picture quality a property of the hour and of two home lines, not of a brand.
Matching tells the same story. Each of them gives you whoever happened to press in the same instant, trimmed by any filter you have paid for, and nobody here has invented anything cleverer.
- Open both rooms on the same evening, an hour apart, on the same device.
- Give each twenty connections without speaking, and write down how many produced a moving picture.
- Compare those two numbers and nothing else; every other difference you noticed was decoration.
So what does separate them
- How many people are inside at the hour you go, which is the only thing that reliably differs.
- Whether a partner can join without a camera.
- What the page does when you idle — some rooms keep you connected, some drop you, and that decides how a long conversation ends.
None of those three appears in a comparison article, because none of them can be checked without opening both and waiting.
Where the reviews come from
Most comparisons of this kind are written without either room being opened, from the feature lists both services publish about themselves, which is why they agree with each other and disagree with anybody who has actually sat there for an evening.
The tell is a paragraph about the sign-up process on a service that has no sign-up.
A second tell is a verdict about picture quality stated without an hour attached to it. Quality here is a property of two home connections at one moment, and any sentence about it that does not name a time of day is describing the writer's evening rather than the service.
None of which makes the reviews dishonest. It makes them a description of what the services say about themselves, which is a legitimate thing to publish and not at all what you came looking for.
The question worth asking instead
Not which room is better, but which room is busy when you are free. Somebody who can only get online at midnight in western Europe is choosing between crowds from different continents, and that choice matters more than every feature list published about either service.